California’s continued drought

By Andrew L. Rypel

As California’s drought deepens, it is worth checking in on the status of water supplies and what might be in store for the rest of the summer, and beyond.

What started with the promise of a wet water year, ended up dry, again. In January, the 8-Station Index showed precipitation totals keeping pace with the wettest year on record. Then it got dry and accumulated totals flat-lined. The final result is a below average water year, although not one of the driest years on record. To be precise, we are 13.3 cumulative inches below the long-term average for the northern Sierras.

Fig. 1. Accumulated precipitation for northern California during the current water year. Graph from the California Department of Water Resources, California Data Exchange Center https://cdec.water.ca.gov/cgi-progs/products/PLOT_ESI.pdf

Current conditions in reservoirs are a mixed bag. Shasta Reservoir remains low at only 40% of capacity, and 49% of the historical average. On this same date in 2021, Shasta was 41% of capacity and 51% of long-term average. Thus conditions in Shasta are very similar to those observed last year. So holding coldwater to support eggs and juvenile winter-run Chinook salmon in the Sacramento River will again be a major challenge this summer. On the heels of a mostly failed year class of winter-run Chinook salmon in 2021, the run is now at perilous risk of extinction. After all, these salmon operate on just a three year life-cycle. Perhaps because of this, efforts have accelerated to move adult winter-run Chinook salmon into coldwater habitats above Shasta Reservoir and into upper Battle Creek. Juvenile outmigrants would have to be trapped and moved around structures on their way out (‘two-way trap and haul’), or fishways re-operated for the specific benefit of salmon (‘one-way trap and haul’). Neither management approaches have been attempted at scale before in these systems. Two-way trap and haul is notoriously expensive and managers have reluctantly avoided it in the past (Lusardi and Moyle 2017).

Comparison of California reservoir levels in 2021 (left) to the same date in 2022 (right). Figures and data from the California Department of Water Resources, California Data Exchange Center https://cdec.water.ca.gov/resapp/RescondMain

Other reservoirs are faring better than one might expect. Oroville is at 53% of capacity and 67% of the historical average. For comparison, at this same point in 2021, Oroville was at 36% capacity and 46% of the historical average. Folsom Reservoir stands at a whopping 88% capacity and 111% of the long-term average – quite good for this point in the drought. This also compares favorably to only 34% of capacity and 43% of the long-term average for Folsom at the same date in 2021.

One potentially interesting observation is that many locally-operated reservoirs appear to be doing particularly well. New Bullard’s Bar and Don Pedro sport 102% and 82% of long-term average, respectively. These reservoirs were also decently full during 2021. Yet, the architecture of these reservoirs may partially explain this dynamic. For example, New Bullard’s Bar is a large capacity reservoir (969,600 acre-foot) but drains a watershed that is comparatively small; the entire Yuba River watershed is 857,600 acres. Similarly, Don Pedro has a capacity of 2,030,000 acre-foot and the entire Tuolumne River drains a watershed of 1,253,120 acres. In this sense, reservoirs with a high capacity:watershed ratio reservoirs may be more slowly impacted, and thus more durable over longer drought. Grantham et al. 2014 ranked all major dams in California based on their degree of regulation (DOR). Both of these reservoirs had DOR values well >1, which was a threshold identified in the study for strong hydrologic regulation. 

It is likely that high air and water temperatures will occur again this summer, as temperatures have been high for recent years. This will have specific and diffuse socioecological impacts. During the last drought, increased temperatures led to parched soils and stressed trees, and ultimately major forest mortality events (Keen et al. 2022). Obviously, drought also increases frequency and severity of wildfires. The top seven largest wildfires in California history all occurred within the last 4 years. Last summer, the Dixie Fire was the largest of the 2021 wildfires, burning close to 1M acres in Butte, Plumas, Shasta, Tehama, and Lassen Counties. As of writing, there are already seven active wildfires burning. How many major wildfires will accumulate during 2022?

Groundwater is taking a major hit. Water right curtailment orders will occur again this growing season. Growers that have planted annual crops will likely rely on groundwater in an attempt to finish. Tree growers with young crops may be forced to use groundwater or purchase water at high prices to try to keep trees alive. California produces ~80% of the world’s almonds and acreage planted has been growing, despite drought risk. Declining groundwater stores will stress rural wells that will run dry or become contaminated by nitrates. Land subsidence from reduced groundwater will impact the capacity for canals to operate properly. Finally, overdraft of groundwater supplies from this year (and previous years, such as 2021) will make SGMA objectives even more difficult to obtain, and require repayment of aquifers for additional drought pumping in future years for many basins.

The Delta ecosystem continues its sad decline. The delta smelt is virtually extinct from the wild, and although releases of hatchery smelt have been initiated, the habitat issues that historically plagued smelt remain unaddressed. To a large extent they have gotten worse. Water temperatures continue to increase, and increased temperatures are a major factor in recruitment failures of smelt (Komorosky et al. 2015). Longfin smelt are declining behind delta smelt (Eakin 2021). Warmer temperatures and clearer waters (due to effects of non-native clams) have intensified the rate of spread of invasive aquatic plants. The switch of fish habitats from cold turbid waters to warm, clear and plant filled habitats has shifted the ecological regime in the Delta to favor non-native fishes such as black basses. These species in turn, compete and predate on native fishes, which cause further declines in Sacramento Valley and Delta endemics.

Castaic Reservoir as seen at 46% capacity during the 2014 drought. Photo from Planet Labs Inc, and downloaded from https://commons.wikimedia.org

Other drought-related impacts are emergent. Water prices are increasing across the board. San Diego County Water Authority will be charging close to $2,000 per acre foot for untreated water in 2023. Many growers that have elected to sell water rather than grow have received record sale prices. These effects are being further compounded by macroeconomic inflation. Urban water restrictions have already been put in place in much of the state. The economic fallout of agricultural water shortages will result in rising unemployment and financial stress to agricultural communities and various irrigation districts. Amidst drought conditions, an interesting plan emerged earlier this month that involved the state potentially purchasing senior water rights. The details and fate of this plan remain murky. As water becomes more expensive and scarce, there may be less interest and prioritization of environmental programs, even though drought is the time when these programs might be most needed by wildlife.

Andrew L. Rypel is a professor of Wildlife, Fish & Conservation Biology and Co-Director of the Center for Watershed Sciences at the University of California, Davis.

Further reading

Börk, K., A.L. Rypel, S. Yarnell, A. Willis, P.B Moyle, J. Medellin-Azuara, J. Lund, and R. Lusardi. 2022. Considerations for developing an environmental water right in California, https://californiawaterblog.com/2022/06/12/considerations-for-developing-an-environmental-water-right-in-california/

Börk, K., A.L. Rypel, and P. Moyle. 2020. New science or just spin: science charade in the Delta, https://californiawaterblog.com/2020/03/15/new-science-or-just-spin-science-charade-in-the-delta/

Eakin, M. 2021. Assessing the distribution and abundance of larval longfin smelt: what can a larval monitoring program tell us about the distribution of a rare species? California Fish and Wildlife Special CESA Issue: 189-202.

Grantham, T.E., J.H. Viers, and P.B. Moyle. 2014. Systematic screening of dams for environmental flow assessment and implementation. Bioscience 64: 1006-1018.

Keen, R.M., S.L. Voelker, S.Y.S. Wang, B.J. Bentz, M.L. Gouldon, C.R. Dangerfield, C.C. Reed, S.M. Hood, A.Z. Csank, T.E. Dawson, A.G. Merschel, and C.J. Still. 2022. Changes in tree drought sensitivity provided early warning signals to the California drought and forest mortality event. Global Change Biology 28: 1119-1132. 

Jessoe, K., J. Medellin-Azuara, P. Moyle, J. Durand, and A. Willis. 2021. A few lessons for California’s new drought. California Waterblog https://californiawaterblog.com/2021/05/16/a-few-lessons-for-californias-new-drought/

Komoroske, L.M., R.E. Connon, K.M. Jeffries, and N.A. Fangue. 2015. Linking transcriptional responses to organismal tolerance reveals mechanisms of thermal sensitivity in a mesothermal endangered fish. Molecular Ecology 24: 4960-4981.

Lund, J., T. Harter, R. Gailey, R. Frank, G. Fogg. 2015. The Earth is falling! – land subsidence and water management in California. California Waterblog https://californiawaterblog.com/2015/12/27/the-earth-is-falling-land-subsidence-and-water-management-in-california/

Lusardi, R.A., and P.B. Moyle. 2017. Two-way trap and haul as a conservation strategy for anadromous Salmonids. Fisheries 42: 478-487.

Moyle, P., K. Börk, J. Durand, T.C. Hung, and A.L. Rypel. 2021. 2021: Is this the year that wild delta smelt become extinct? https://californiawaterblog.com/2021/01/10/2021-is-this-the-year-that-wild-delta-smelt-become-extinct/

Rypel, A.L. 2021. Do largemouth bass like droughts? https://californiawaterblog.com/2021/05/02/do-largemouth-bass-like-droughts/

https://wildlife.ca.gov/News/pilot-project-to-return-salmon-to-their-historical-habitat-above-shasta-dam-receives-initial-funding

https://wildlife.ca.gov/News/endangered-california-salmon-returned-to-safer-waters-after-more-than-a-century

https://www.fooddive.com/news/despite-drought-almonds-will-keep-on-growing/608839/

https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-05-09/new-bill-aims-to-limit-frenzy-of-california-well-drilling

https://www.fws.gov/press-release/2021-12/delta-smelt-released-wild-first-time?ref=delta-smelt-released-into-wild-for-first-time&_ID=37069

https://www.kpbs.org/news/local/2022/05/27/san-diego-county-water-authority-proposes-water-rate-hike-citing-rising-costs

About andrewrypel

Andrew Rypel is an Associate Professor and the Peter B. Moyle and California Trout Chair of coldwater fish ecology at the University of California, Davis. He is a faculty member in the Department of Wildlife, Fish & Conservation Biology and Co-Director of the Center for Watershed Sciences.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to California’s continued drought

  1. This post by Andrew Rypel dated June 19, 2022 (“California’s continued drought”) states:
    “Shasta Reservoir remains low at only 40% of capacity, and 49% of the historical average. On this same date in 2021, Shasta was 41% of capacity and 51% of long-term average. Thus conditions in Shasta are very similar to those observed last year. So holding cold water to support eggs and juvenile winter-run Chinook salmon in the Sacramento River will again be a major challenge this summer. On the heels of a mostly failed year class of winter-run Chinook salmon in 2021, the run is now at perilous risk of extinction.”

    Given that the Sacramento River winter-run Chinook salmon “is now at perilous risk of extinction”, sufficient carryover storage to protect eggs and juvenile winter-run is critical to their survival as a species. In a critically dry year above Balls Ferry,1,600 taf has been shown to be the minimum carryover storage necessary for temperature compliance in all months (Finnerty, Anthony A., “Effects of Shasta Lake Carryover Storage and Annual Releases on Meeting Sacramento River Temperature Objectives: Initial Studies”, pp. 8,11, May 4, 1993.) This report is available on my website (see below) under the Environmental Reports category.

  2. Joseph Rizzi says:

    Delta Louvers to hold the fresh water in the Delta and restrict the Sea water push inland to the ports. Less than $100 million for 3 locations with fences and gates with louvers that are controlled by the tides (like a dryer vent) anchored to a connected (removable and movable) 20 ton bases.

Leave a Reply