By Karrigan Börk
. . .
Editor’s Note: Center for Watershed Sciences Director Karrigan Bork gave the welcoming address at the California Water Policy Conference at UC Davis last week. His comments, edited and condensed for the blog, are reproduced below.
. . .
Thank you for the invitation to speak here at the California Water Policy Conference. I love the theme this year: “Adapting Together.” It’s a great theme for where we are right now. In this opening talk, as I understand it, I have two jobs: to welcome you to UC Davis and to set the stage for discussion.
So, welcome to UC Davis! I’m so excited to be hosting the Conference on campus in this, its 30th year. What an accomplishment. Congratulations!
UC Davis is an ideal spot for a conference like this, for people with very different opinions to come together and talk about solutions. UC Davis has a long history of providing independent science and an independent voice on California’s water and agricultural challenges. From the public trust doctrine to the Williamson Act, from mechanical tomato harvesting to baby salmon in rice fields, from vineyards to groundwater sustainability, indeed, on nearly every water issue from the Sierra to the Sea, UC Davis experts have been deeply enmeshed in California water.
That work has been made possible, in part, due to the great working (and funding) relationships that UC Davis has with so many of you. Thank you! I think of things like the Mondavi Food and Wine Institute, the new Resnick Center for Agricultural Innovation, widespread grant support, and of course, the UC Davis Center for Watershed Sciences, where I currently have the pleasure of serving as Director.
At the Center, we provide interdisciplinary, independent analysis of critical water challenges, particularly in California, in pursuit of actionable solutions. We’re focused on applied science for real-world solutions. To learn more about the work we’re doing at the Center, you can read the latest edition of the California Water Blog, which provides an overview of the work we’re presenting at the Bay Delta Science Conference this week.
OK, so, on to my second job. Let’s set the stage a little bit. You all remember the curse, “May you live in interesting times?” Well, I’m not sure who we made angry, but we’re living in interesting water times, that’s for sure. Just think about what we’ve got going on in the next month:
First, on October 1st, the Department of Interior’s 2027–2028 Operating Guidelines for the Colorado River go into effect. We’re talking about divvying up water for 40 million people across a region facing long-term drought, where managers are holding on to adequate reservoir levels by their fingernails. See Image 1. We’re also talking about a potential reduction in use of 440,000 acre-feet from California alone. The real question on this will be whether the states can work something out over the first few weeks of October. Nevada has already filed suit in district court, and if the states don’t come to agreement, we’re almost certain to see this in the U.S. Supreme Court before too long.

Second, the deadline for public comments on the State Water Board’s revised Draft Water Right Permit for Sites Reservoir is October 5. This is the second bite at the apple for the Sites Project Authority, which wasn’t pleased with the permitting decision it got from the Water Board’s Administrative Hearings Office last March. The public hearing isn’t until November 4, but, given that Sites would be the 8th largest reservoir in California, I think Sites gets to count as an October issue.
Third, on October 7th, the California Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Bring Back the Kern v. City of Bakersfield, a pivotal case on how much deference is due to the legislature when it makes a determination on the reasonableness of a particular water use, and on whether FGC Section 5937, requiring dam owners to release enough water to keep fish in good condition, is a legislative determination that such use of water is reasonable. Full disclosure: I’m on the board of one of the plaintiffs in that case, so you should investigate it and draw your own conclusions. To be clear, though, I think this is a big deal case, with implications for how much deference courts will give the legislature and the Board going forward. Interesting times.
Fourth, on October 15th, the Delta Stewardship Council will hold a public hearing to consider appeals concerning the California Department of Water Resources’ revised Certification of Consistency with the Delta Plan for the Delta Conveyance Project. This is the second round at the Council for the Delta Conveyance Project.
And fifth, of course, we have the upcoming Water Board hearings on the Bay Delta Plan, Oct. 28-29. The draft plan includes both the Healthy Rivers and Landscapes approach and the regulatory backstop, but I don’t need to tell you all about it. Also, no lawsuits yet, at least not about this piece of the plan, but only because it isn’t ready yet.
I’m leaving a lot out here: SGMA litigation hearings this month; the public comment deadline for the new Clean Water Act rule proposal; the November vote on the Tijuana River sewage treatment plant; whether the baby winter run Chinook salmon will survive water temps below Shasta Dam over the next month (see Image 2); the upcoming Mono Lake hearings; the new data center disclosure laws; the Eel River dam removal; and the news that the Scott River dried up last week…. It’s an interesting time!

This moment feels particularly weighty, and just looking at concrete happenings in October undersells it. I know this is delicate territory, but let’s consider the broader political situation. I’ll try to tread lightly.
At the federal level, we’ve had a massive sea change on the environmental and water side. Consider the people. The federal science and environmental agencies have lost huge numbers of long-time employees. Agencies like the Bureau of Reclamation and the Army Corps have also seen huge losses. This is a generational blow to federal scientific, regulatory, and operational capacity, and whatever your politics, this creates real questions about remaining institutional capability, especially for things like managing the Central Valley Project.
Regulatory changes have also undermined foundational environmental laws that have governed business for the last 50 years. Consider just the Endangered Species Act changes. With the recent regulatory changes and guidance, we have literally no idea what actions violate the ESA anymore. This administration has taken the position that the ESA only prohibits actions that are “intentionally and purposefully directed at a particular animal.” The recent FWS Director’s memo said that “Felling a tree is not a take of the bats roosting in it unless the tree is felled for the purpose of killing or capturing them.” By the same logic, killing salmon by drying up a river wouldn’t be a take of the salmon in the river, if it was done to make use of the water and not for the purpose of killing salmon. Think about that for a second. I’ll let you all figure out what that means for the CVP biological opinions and the associated mitigation projects. This is just the administration’s take, of course, but the ESA has a citizen suit provision, which means that judges all over the country will soon be coming to their own conclusions about what actions violate the ESA. I’m glad I’m not trying to decide if I need an ESA permit right now.
Even more broadly, we’re not merely arguing about individual water projects or environmental rules. This administration is challenging some of the baseline principles that have structured Western water policy for generations. Most centrally, states have long had broad authority over their own water law, and the federal government has deferred to that authority. For example, the 1902 Reclamation Act requires Reclamation to conform with state laws relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water used in irrigation. The Corps of Engineers often operates under a similar requirement, and the CWA, the WIIN Act, and the CVPIA have similar provisions. In the famous 1978 case of California v. the United States, the Court wrote, “[T]he history of the relationship between the Federal Government and the States in the reclamation of the arid lands of the Western States is both long and involved, but through it runs the consistent thread of purposeful and continued deference to state water law by Congress.” This deference has been fundamental to Western water law, and it’s what lets states decide how to govern themselves. Recent presidential proclamations and actions by agency political appointees call it into question.
On the state side, things are also “interesting.” In some ways, the state seems divided against itself. California is leading the fight against the federal government’s efforts to reduce regulatory oversight and to cut funding for science. It has poured funds into the historic (and so far, wildly successful) Klamath Dam removal and is making great strides in respecting the state’s sovereign tribes through land back and tribal water use protection. At the same time, the state’s independent agencies face unprecedented political pressure on their decision-making as the Governor seeks to achieve his water policy objectives before he leaves office. It’s certainly an interesting time to be a regulator in California.
Where does that leave us? The environmental community is reeling from the federal changes and from the state conflicts. Tribal power in California is on the rise. Much of the water user community is about to get directly involved in restoration on a historic scale, while a few members of the community seem to be smelling blood in the water. And soon we’ll be welcoming a new governor, new legislators, and a whole new set of appointees. It is an interesting time.
I want to add one last layer. Think about the last four years in California hydrology. We have had remarkably average precipitation for the last three years, and a very wet year the year before that. See Image 3. I know there’s variation across the state, but really, we’ve been tremendously lucky. All this legal wrangling, all this political pressure, that’s been happening during a run of good years. We haven’t had a run this good since the late 1990s, and the last round before that was another 20+ years back. This is unusual. These good years have pulled some salmon populations back from the brink, increased groundwater storage in many areas, and put water back in many reservoirs. But this is not normal. And it’s especially not something we can rely on with our changing climate. Imagine how difficult our current questions become when the hydrology turns against us.

The expectation for the future is more drought. More steep, sudden droughts. More destructive flooding. More variability. More wild volatility. It’s not good news. And we can’t just hope for more years like the last four. Hope is not a strategy.
Bottom line, we live in a state with a crazy climate, and it’s going to get even crazier. We live in a state that values its environment and cares about its native species. We live in a state that also values its urban, municipal, and agricultural water use and water users. We have a tremendous agriculture sector that grows food for the world. These are our enduring truths, and the tensions they create aren’t going away, no matter the current political noise.
This context makes the work that we’re doing here today that much more important. “Adapting together.” That’s where we started, and that’s where we must go in the future. I’ve often said that, in California water, we fight before we figure out how to work together. Conflict, then collaboration. We’ve had a lot of conflict, but we’re increasingly leaning into collaboration. But these unsettling and unsettled times, these interesting times, threaten to destabilize our current collaborations. There’s a temptation to lean into political posturing, to enact policy based on talking points, and to sacrifice the common good for short-term gain. But this is exactly the moment when we need to lean into the collaboration we’ve built, rather than give in to the temptation to embrace more conflict.
Our core challenges remain, but we’re doing really great work on water together. We’re doing great science and improving our data and monitoring. We understand more about water and ecosystem management than ever before. We’re figuring out how to transition to sustainable groundwater use under SGMA, the most transformative water legislation in a generation. We’re putting fish back on floodplains and back above dams. We’re investing in habitat and increasing environmental flows. We’ve seen tremendous innovation in urban water use, recycling, and stormwater capture. We’re growing more food with less water. And we’re bringing new voices to the table. None of that is happening because everybody agrees. It’s happening because people who disagree are finding ways to work together.
We have the capacity and the know-how to keep the momentum going. Let’s keep adapting together. Thank you.
About the Author
Karrigan Börk is a UC Davis Professor of Law and the Director of the Center for Watershed Sciences. His publications run the gamut from California minimum streamflow requirements to a hatchery and genetic management plan for the reintroduction of spring-run Chinook salmon in the San Joaquin River. Prof. Börk graduated with Distinction and Pro Bono Distinction from Stanford Law School in 2009 and completed his Ph.D. dissertation in Ecology at UC Davis in September 2011. His current work focuses on Western water law.
Leave a Reply